- Our Story -

This storied building has served the Silver Creek area for decades.


The building that stands today as The Colony Seafood and Steakhouse was originally built in 1958, opening under the name "The Colony House".  Over the years the building bore several monikers including "The Hanover House", "The Hanover Harbor House", and "Spaghetti Junction". The building had been vacant for two years before being taken over by the LaBarbera family in 1982.

Colony News


NEW - Try our "Quarantinis"!

Served in jugs that serve 6-8 drink, we're now offering large batch cocktails - to go! Margaritas, Bloody Marys, or Arnold Palmer jugs for $29, or Long Island Iced Tea for $39! Put a little fun in your quarantine weekend with Quarantinis! Ask about them when placing your order today!


Now offering Frozen Fridge/Freezer Fillers!

The Colony is now offering FROZEN FRIDGE/FREEZER FILLERS! Personal portions perfect for you, your family, or your neighbors to continue enjoying our Colony quality fare while we’re closed during the week. Starting at $9 and going up to $15, grab some of your Colony favorites and fill your freezers today! These offerings will change, so be sure to like us on Facebook to stay up-to-date, or check out what we're offering on our limited menu here!


Colony to re-open for carry-out!

Beginning this Friday & Saturday, 3/27 & 3/28, the Colony Seafood and Steakhouse will be re-opening under a limited menu for carryout only! Offering your favorite St. Joseph's Day specials to-go, call us to place your orders at (716) 934-4826 *OR* (716) 785-4348. This process will be new for everyone involved, so please bare with us as we iron out the kinks. In these trying times, the Colony is eager to continue offering our loyal guests the culinary experiences they've come to know and love. Check out what we're offering on our limited menu here!


Our Statement on COVID-19

We at the Colony are deeply saddened by the effect of the Coronavirus (COVID-19) on our friends and neighbors everywhere, especially in Italy. We are very proud of our Italian heritage and our hearts and thoughts are in Italy with our loved ones at this time. We would also like to reassure our diners that our objective every day is to provide the safest places to celebrate milestone moments with good food and quality service. Our team has increased the depth and frequency of our cleaning protocols and are taking necessary precautions to maintain a safe environment for our employees and guests alike. Our full statement can be read by clicking here.

Business Hours

Monday - Saturday

4:30PM - 9:30PM


12:30PM - 8:30PM

Stop by Sunday afternoons for Buffalo football!

* * * 

© 2023 by Modello. Proudly created with Wix.com by Andrew Nagoda