top of page

- Menu -

Dine-In & Carryout Dinner MenuHigh quality meals & filling portions at prices that can't be beat!


Appetizers



Soup Du Jour
Cup
$7

Bowl
$9


Crab & Lobster Cakes
$15


Roasted Unstuffed Peppers
Sautéed fresh whole banana peppers, topped with three cheeses & sundried tomatoes
$15
Gluten free
Vegetarian
Mild


Clams Casino
$15


Crispy Chicken Livers
$15


Two Meatballs in Sauce
$14


Boom Boom Shrimp
Crispy fried shrimp tossed in spicy Boom Boom sauce and topped with fresh green onion, over chopped romaine
$15
Mild


Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
5 huge shrimp with cocktail sauce and lemon
$15
Gluten free


Battered Perch/Walleye Fingers
When Available
$16


Crispy Pork Belly
When Available
$15


Horseradish Steak Bites
Sautéed w/ horseradish and mushrooms
$15
Gluten free


Tuna Tataki
Lightly seared Ahi Tuna, served w/ pickled ginger and wasabi
$15
Gluten free


Fried Calamari
Served with home made spaghetti sauce
$15


Char Grilled Oysters New Orleans
Dine-In Only
1/2 Dozen
$13

Dozen
$24


Fried Provolone Balls
$14


French Onion Soup Au Gratin
Cup
$7

Crock
$9


Stuffed Mushrooms
Stuffed with breadcrumbs, onions and ham. Topped with cheese, over cream sauce
$15


Fried Green Tomatoes
Cornmeal crusted, with vidalia onion sauce
$15



Salads



House Salad
$6


House Ceaser Salad
$10



Entrees



Garlic Rubbed Ribeye Steak
$46
Gluten free


Queen Cut Prime Rib
King Cut $58/ Packaged for carryout at MEDIUM RARE ONLY.
$48
Gluten free


Moody Blue Steak
Stuffed with smokey blue cheese and topped with a sweet onion and bacon crust
$36


Center Cut Filet Mignon
$46


Steak Neptune
Sirloin on toast topped with bernaise sauce and fresh shrimp & scallops
$43


Tenderloin Duxelle
8oz Filet stuffed w/ onion & mushroom Duxelle, seared with Peppercorns, served over demi-glaze
$48


Filet Tips And Mushrooms
Served Over Mashed Potatoes
$37
Gluten free


Maple Walnut Pork Chops
Two boneless chops with caramelized apples, walnuts, and maple syrup
$31
Gluten free


Double Cut Pork Chops
w/ mashed potatoes and cabernet mushroom demi glaze
$30


Rack of Lamb Rosemary
1/2 Rack $39/ when available
$69
Gluten free


BBQ Ribs
$38
Gluten free


Crab Stuffed Walleye
Fresh walleye filet stuffed with Jeff's classic seafood stuffing/when available
$34


Crab Stuffed Shrimp
Huge gulf shrimp stuffed with Jeff's crabmeat dressing; baked to perfection
$37


Veal Colony
Breaded Veal with sauteed mushrooms, broccoli & artichoke hearts, with hollaindaise. Add Scampi Shrimp $36
$31


Pan Seared Scallops
Served in a butter wine sauce
$42


Seafood Jambalaya
Spicy creole sauce mixed with fresh white rice, shrimp, and scallops
$37
Gluten free
Mild


Surf & Turf
2 5oz Lobster tails served with an 8 oz sirloin steak
Mini
$44

Regular
$52


Steak & Shrimp New Orleans
8 oz. blackened sirloin & huge shrimp served over rice and Creole sauce
$43
Gluten free
Mild


Twin Maine Lobster Tails
$44


Buffalo Blue Salmon
Baked and topped with home made blue cheese and panko bread crumbs
$34


Nawlins Shrimp & Grits
w/ andouille sausage, bacon and cajun shrimp
$35
Mild


Blackened Mahi New Orleans
served over creole, with white rice
$35
Gluten free
Mild


Blackened Chicken New Orleans
Blackened chicken served over rice and Creole sauce
$29
Gluten free
Mild


Seafood Cioppino
Clams, Mussels, Fish, Scallops & Shrimp in a tomato wine sauce
$43
Gluten free
Mild


Fettucine Alfredo
w/ broccoli only 24 w/ chicken $28 w/ shrimp $32
Chicken & Broccoli
$24

Shrimp
$27


Parmigiana
Chicken
$29

Veal
$30


Spaghetti & Meatballs
Al dente spaghetti & two meatballs
$24



Light Fare
Served with french fries and pickles


Colony 1/2 Pound Bacon Cheeseburger
served with fries
$20


Beef on Weck w/ French Fries
Regular
$20

Colossal
$24


Chicken Fingers
served with fries
$16



Sharing Platters



Buffalo Style Chicken Wings
10 wings, classic Buffalo style medium
$18


Sriracha Bourbon Rib Platter
A full rack of ribs smothered in sriracha bourbon BBQ sauce
$38
Gluten free
Mild



Fish Fry
Available on FRIDAY ONLY. Served with french fries, cole slaw, tarter sauce, and either macaroni or potato salad.


Lake Erie Perch Fry
*Seasonal*
$21


Battered Walleye Fry
*seasonal*
$21


Battered Haddock Fry
$20

Daily specials will be uploaded to our Facebook page as they change.
Prices subject to change.

© 2023 by Modello. Proudly created with Wix.com by Andrew Nagoda

bottom of page